FAILED STATE INDIA — THE NARRATIVE – Part 4
*By Ahmed Sohail Siddiqui*
There was a time when the term “Failed State” was reserved for war-torn nations whose governments had collapsed under the weight of foreign invasions, civil wars, or economic ruin. Today, that phrase finds uncomfortable resonance in the very land whose leaders shout the loudest about being the “world’s largest democracy.” India, in 2025, is not a failed state in the conventional sense — it is something worse: a *state in denial of its failure*.
The international perception of India as an emerging power is increasingly at odds with the ground reality. Behind the glossy GDP figures and choreographed foreign visits lies an ugly truth — the collapse of constitutional morality, the weaponisation of institutions, the corruption of the judiciary, and the total capture of the national narrative by a nexus of political and corporate oligarcy
**The Anatomy of a Managed Collapse**
A failed state doesn’t have to dissolve into anarchy overnight. It can also rot slowly, with the decay camouflaged by propaganda. In India’s case, this rot has been meticulously managed by those who claim to be saviours of the nation.
* **The Congress-BJP Consensus**: While the public is made to believe these two parties are bitter rivals, their backstage cooperation on key issues — from corporate land grabs to suppressing dissent — is an open secret in political corridors.
* **The Judiciary’s Co-option**: From shielding billionaires accused of land fraud to rubber-stamping anti-minority laws, the higher judiciary has moved from being the guardian of the Constitution to the security guard of the ruling class.
* **The Media as Enforcer**: TV channels and newspapers act as outsourced propaganda departments, framing resistance as sedition and corruption as patriotism.
**Manufacturing Nationalism, Suppressing Truth**
The greatest success of the failed-state architects has been the weaponisation of nationalism. Dissent is criminalised as “anti-national,” minorities are demonised as “threats,” and the majority is fed a diet of manufactured pride while real issues — unemployment, agrarian distress, public health collapse — are buried.
The result? An uninformed majority and a terrified minority. Both trapped in a carefully crafted psychological war where the truth is irrelevant, and loyalty to the narrative is everything.
**The Dawood-Corporate-Political Shadow**
Our earlier volumes have traced the unholy nexus of Dawood-linked operatives, corporate giants like Ambani-Adani, and political enablers across party lines. This is not conspiracy theory — this is documented fact, seen in cases like the **Antilia Waqf Land Grab** and the 188 similar encroachment that remain untouched despite court inquiries.
The message is clear: the law exists for the poor; immunity exists for the powerful.
**Why the World Won’t Call India a Failed State**
Here lies the dangerous genius of the system — as long as foreign investors profit, as long as India plays its role in the US-led Indo-Pacific strategy, and as long as Bollywood continues exporting the dream of “shining India,” the global community will look away.
The world doesn’t see the suppressed journalists, jailed activists, and dispossessed farmers. And when it does, it shrugs — because the failed state serves its global purpose.
**The Road Ahead**
A failed state narrative is not inevitable; it is a choice. India’s ruling and opposition elites have chosen to protect each other at the cost of the nation’s democratic soul.
If history teaches us anything, it is this: nations don’t collapse in a vacuum — they collapse when their citizens accept that collapse as the “new normal.”
India stands at that edge today. The only question is — will its people step back, or will they be pushed over by the very hands they once trusted?
*****
Part 5
THE FAILED STATE INDIA – NARRATIVE
*By Ahmed Sohail Siddiqui*
When a state loses its moral compass, its constitutional backbone, and its ability to deliver justice to its citizens — it does not need a foreign power to declare it a failure. The rot is visible in the daily lives of its people, in the cynical manipulation of its institutions, and in the surrender of sovereignty to corporate, communal, and criminal interests. India today is living that reality — dressed in the cosmetic garb of a “rising global power” while its foundations crumble beneath the weight of lies, violence, and systemic betrayal.
**1. The Illusion of Stability**
The ruling elite — whether under the saffron banner of the BJP-RSS combine or the feigned secularism of Congress — has mastered the art of manufacturing stability for international consumption. They speak of growth, democracy, and unity in global forums, while presiding over lynch mobs, custodial murders, and the demolition of minority rights at home. This is not governance — it is theatre for foreign investment, where the script is written by corporate boardrooms and the actors wear political labels.
**2. Judiciary as a Co-Conspirator**
A failed state is one where courts become tools of power, not protectors of justice. India’s judiciary today shows selective courage — roaring like a lion when protecting the privileges of the rich and powerful, but reduced to a whisper when confronted with constitutional crimes against the poor, the marginalised, and the dissenters. From the prolonged incarceration of journalists under draconian laws to the refusal to hear cases involving blatant hate speech by ruling party leaders, the judiciary has become a willing participant in India’s institutional decay.
**3. Media as the Ministry of Propaganda**
Independent media — the mirror of any democracy — has been systematically replaced by cheerleaders of the regime. Anchors who once questioned power now compete for the privilege of becoming its loudspeakers. Facts are manufactured, opponents are vilified, and the most pressing crises — from unemployment to agrarian distress — are buried under the noise of manufactured nationalism. This is not an accident; it is the outcome of years of corporate-media-political nexus-building where truth became a commodity too expensive to afford.
**4. The Criminalisation of Politics**
The failed state is not only corrupt in governance but criminal in structure. India’s Parliament is now home to dozens of MPs facing serious criminal charges — including murder, extortion, and communal incitement. The very institution that should uphold the rule of law has become a sanctuary for those who break it. When the protectors of law are indistinguishable from the violators of law, the very idea of justice collapses.
**5. Waqf Land and the Loot of Minority Assets**
The theft of Waqf land — as in the Antilia case and over 188 similar corporate encroachment — is a chilling example of state-enabled plunder. Laws meant to protect minority endowments have been amended to ensure corporate access, while community leaders are bribed or silenced. A failed state does not merely ignore the rights of its minorities; it actively dismantles them for profit and political convenience.
**6. Social Fabric in Tatters**
Communal hatred has become policy, not just politics. Violence against Muslims, Christians, and Dalits is met not with condemnation but with silent endorsement or open celebration by those in power. A nation that rewards hate over harmony has already crossed the threshold into failure — for no state can sustain itself when its own citizens live as targets, not equals.
**7. Conclusion — The Warning**
India’s decline into a failed state is not a distant possibility — it is an unfolding reality. The tragedy is not that the warning signs are invisible, but that they are ignored by those entrusted with the nation’s future. History teaches us that no amount of GDP growth, military muscle, or diplomatic rhetoric can save a country whose institutions, morality, and social unity have collapsed.
If there is to be a redemption, it must come not from political messiahs or corporate saviours, but from the people reclaiming the republic that was stolen from them. Until then, the words “world’s largest democracy” will remain nothing more than a hollow slogan for a failed state in denial. ( Concluded )
*****